Unveiling the Biggest Red Flags when Hiring a Contractor

Are you in need of a reliable contractor to carry out your kitchen remodel, bathroom remodel, or home addition project? It’s crucial to be aware of the warning signs that can help you avoid hiring an unprofessional or unreliable contractor. By keeping an eye out for these red flags, you can save yourself from potential headaches, delays, and financial losses.

Last year, in one of our classic blog posts, we ran over our process for qualifying a contractor. In the year since, we’ve seen countless homeowners recount horror stories of contractors that never showed up, never finished the job, or overpriced projects that they underdelivered on. In this guide, we will quickly run through the most important steps to ensuring your contractor is reliable and worth your time.

Inconsistent or Nonexistent Portfolio and References

One of the first red flags to watch out for when hiring a contractor is an inconsistent or nonexistent portfolio and references. A reputable contractor should be able to provide you with a portfolio showcasing their previous work and a list of satisfied clients who can vouch for their services. If a contractor fails to provide any evidence of their past projects or refuses to share references, it’s a clear warning sign that they may not have the necessary experience or a positive track record.

Be sure to check online portfolio and review sites such as Angi, Houzz, and Google Reviews.

Lack of Proper Licensing and Insurance

Another major red flag when considering a contractor is their lack of proper licensing and insurance. A professional contractor should have the necessary licenses and permits required by local authorities to perform the specific type of work you need. Additionally, they should carry adequate insurance coverage, including general liability and workers’ compensation insurance, to protect you from any potential accidents, damages, or lawsuits that may occur during the project.

In the State of Connecticut, contractor licenses can be verified using the following website: https://www.elicense.ct.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx

Poor Communication and Unreliable Timelines

Effective communication is vital for a successful contractor-client relationship. If a contractor is unresponsive, fails to return calls or emails promptly, or shows a lack of interest in understanding your project requirements, it’s a significant red flag. Furthermore, be cautious if a contractor provides unrealistic or vague timelines for completing the project. Clear and reliable communication, along with a realistic project timeline, are essential for ensuring a smooth and satisfactory experience.

Most larger contracting companies will use a project management software such as CoConstruct or Buildertrend to allow for easier communication with your project manager. Ask any prospective contractor how they handle staying in contact throughout the length of your project, as you should know who to contact regarding questions or sudden occurrences.

Unprofessional Behavior and Poor Work Ethic

When evaluating potential contractors, pay attention to their behavior and work ethic. Unprofessional conduct, such as showing up late to meetings, failing to meet deadlines, or not respecting your property, can be indicative of a lack of professionalism and commitment to quality. Additionally, observe their work ethic during the initial stages of the project. If they appear disorganized, unmotivated, or exhibit subpar craftsmanship, it’s a clear red flag that their work may not meet your expectations.

Excessive Upfront Payments or Unreasonable Estimates

Be cautious if a contractor asks for an excessive upfront payment or provides estimates that seem too good to be true. Reputable contractors typically require a reasonable deposit or progress payments throughout the project, with the final payment upon satisfactory completion. Asking for a substantial upfront payment could indicate financial instability or the potential for unfinished work. Similarly, if an estimate is significantly lower than other contractors’ bids, it may suggest hidden costs or substandard materials. We always recommend having 3 separate contractors quote your project to give you a variety of options at different price points and levels of quality. Having other quotes to compare a company’s with ensures that their price isn’t concerningly high or low compared to the industry standard.


When searching for a contractor, it’s crucial to be aware of the biggest red flags that may indicate potential problems. Inconsistent or nonexistent portfolios and references, lack of proper licensing and insurance, and poor communication and unreliable timelines are all warning signs that should not be ignored. By paying attention to these red flags and conducting thorough research before making a hiring decision, you can increase your chances of finding a reputable and reliable contractor who will deliver high-quality workmanship and a positive experience.

Published On: May 23rd, 2023 / Categories: Home Improvement Contractor, Home Remodeling /

Need a Contractor? We’re happy to help. Get in touch to request a quote.

Active Projects
Years of Experience
Google Review Rating